FACTS: Owner Shai Harmelech of Cable America, Inc., illegally distributed Russian-language programming to twenty specific apartment houses. Cable America collected and kept the fees for this service while pirating the signal. Russian Media Group filed suit against Harmelech and Cable America, and the U.S. District Court issued a preliminary injunction under the Illinois Cable Piracy Act. Harmelech and Cable America appealed.
LEGAL ISSUE: 1. Was the injunction on Harmelech and Cable America too broad?
2. Can this injunction be overturned based on preemption?
3. How can plaintiffs prove to be an “aggrieved party?”
4. Can this lawsuit be barred based off of a previous settlement?
DECISION: The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit upheld the preliminary injunction and affirmed the district court’s orders.
RATIONALE: There was evidence of Harmelech’s misconduct of illegally distributing Russian-language programming, and he refused to comply with the injunction by not disconnecting the receivers. Evidence shows that Harmelech’s business model was to steal television programming and resell it at a discount. The injunction was not too broad because Harmelech showed a pattern of misconduct and record of dishonesty in trial court, including continuing to pirate the signal and falsely claiming that he did not have the power to disconnect the receivers.
In a civil suit, if you do not present an issue to the district court, you cannot use it in an appellate court. The defendants did not try to use the defense of preemption until they were in the appellate court.
In order to figure out if someone is considered an “aggrieved party,” there must be a large amount of evidence proving the party suffered. Russian Media Group was able to prove that they were the “aggrieved party” through evidence that includes, but is not limited to, lost business subscribers and being excluded from entire buildings. Russian Media Group also showed that they lost subscribers during the launch of Cable America.
A lawsuit can be barred if the issue has already been resolved. However, this case did not reflect the issues in the 2001 suit involving these same two parties. The defendants in this case wanted the case barred based off of the previous suit. The court did not discuss this because the previous case involved completely different events.